Worked example Here is a teaching sample. It is not customer data and not a result from a live client.
Lease A start rent $40,000
Lease B start rent $37,200
Discount rate 8%
Sample NPV A $364,469
Lease A vs Lease B — the teaching lease Metric Lease A Lease B Start rent $40,000 $37,200 Year-1 extras $9,000 $9,630 Year-1 credit $15,000 $8,250 Sample NPV $364,469 $353,746
Cash-flow walk — the teaching lease Year Rent Extras Credit Cash out Value today Year 1 $40,000 $9,000 $15,000 $34,000 $31,481 Year 2 $41,600 $9,270 $0 $50,870 $43,613 Year 3 $43,264 $9,548 $0 $52,812 $41,924 Year 4 $44,995 $9,835 $0 $54,830 $40,302 Year 5 $46,794 $10,130 $0 $56,924 $38,742 Year 6 $48,198 $10,434 $0 $58,632 $36,948 Year 7 $49,644 $10,747 $0 $60,391 $35,238 Year 8 $51,133 $11,069 $0 $62,202 $33,606 Year 9 $52,667 $11,401 $0 $64,068 $32,050 Year 10 $54,247 $11,743 $0 $65,990 $30,566 Sample NPV — — — — $364,469
Both options use the same rate. The lower bar is not automatically the better lease. How to read the sample Sample NPV for the teaching lease is about $364,469. A second path lands near $353,746. That gap is a talking point, not a promise.
A build-out check arrives while rent is still low. If one path wins only because a credit sat in the wrong year, start over.
Year notes for the teaching lease Year 1 of the teaching lease has rent of $40,000. Shared building cost is $9,000. A credit of $15,000 lowers the cash you pay that year. Cash out this year is about $34,000. A build-out check arrives while rent is still low. Later cash gets a shrink for time. At 8 percent, year 1 is worth about $31,481 today. Next, year 2 rent is $41,600. CAM, which is a shared building cost, is $9,270. There is no credit in this year. You pay about $50,870 this year after extras and credits. The step-up starts. The credit is gone. Time shrinks later cash. At 8 percent, year 2 is worth about $43,613 today. Then year 3 rent is $43,264. Extras for the building come to $9,548. Credits skip this year. The net cash this year is about $52,812. Escalation is now the main story. Waiting has a price. At 8 percent, year 3 is worth about $41,924 today. After that, year 4 rent is $44,995. The shared building cost this time is $9,835. No extra credit shows up this year. Cash out this year is about $54,830. Later rent is bigger, but we shrink it more. Later cash gets a shrink for time. At 8 percent, year 4 is worth about $40,302 today. In year 5 of the teaching lease, rent is $46,794. Shared building cost is $10,130. There is no credit in this year. You pay about $56,924 this year after extras and credits. The last year still belongs in the sum. Time shrinks later cash. At 8 percent, year 5 is worth about $38,742 today. Year 6 of the teaching lease has rent of $48,198. CAM, which is a shared building cost, is $10,434. Credits skip this year. The net cash this year is about $58,632. Keep this later year in the sum for the sample. Waiting has a price. At 8 percent, year 6 is worth about $36,948 today. Next, year 7 rent is $49,644. Extras for the building come to $10,747. No extra credit shows up this year. Cash out this year is about $60,391. The row still belongs in the sum for the long path. Later cash gets a shrink for time. At 8 percent, year 7 is worth about $35,238 today. Then year 8 rent is $51,133. The shared building cost this time is $11,069. There is no credit in this year. You pay about $62,202 this year after extras and credits. Keep this later year in the sum for the long path. Time shrinks later cash. At 8 percent, year 8 is worth about $33,606 today. After that, year 9 rent is $52,667. Shared building cost is $11,401. Credits skip this year. The net cash this year is about $64,068. The row still belongs in the sum for the long path. Waiting has a price. At 8 percent, year 9 is worth about $32,050 today. In year 10 of the teaching lease, rent is $54,247. CAM, which is a shared building cost, is $11,743. No extra credit shows up this year. Cash out this year is about $65,990. Keep this later year in the sum for the long path. Later cash gets a shrink for time. At 8 percent, year 10 is worth about $30,566 today. Add those year values. The sample NPV for the teaching lease is about $364,469. This is a teaching sample, not a client result.
See how the discount rate works